Kitchen CSI: Unmasking the White Suspects (Salt, Sugar, and Flour!)

Every Day is an Experiment.

Take a look at those pure white powders in your kitchen. Sugar, salt, flour. They look identical, but what if they got shuffled up and you couldn’t tell which was which? How would you identify them? (No tasting allowed!) This time, we’re diving into a “Science Mystery” lurking in our daily lives, and we’ll show you an inquiry-based experiment where junior high students rose to the challenge. They were presented with three mysterious white powders: A, B, and C. Could they use the power of science to expose the true identity of these “White Suspects”?

Here are our “suspects.” Some students might have an educated guess just by looking, but science isn’t satisfied with a “hunch.” We need evidence.

The Investigation Begins! What Experiments Will Unmask the Powders?
The students were told upfront that the suspects were one of flour, sugar, or salt. The first step was for each group to formulate their “Investigation Plan”—their experimental strategy. As long as it wasn’t dangerous, anything was fair game. That’s the beauty of inquiry.

This group’s strategy seems to be dissolving them in water first. And then, burning them…? That’s a pretty bold plan!

Once the plan was set, they wrote down their needed “Investigation Tools”: beakers, test tubes, and… a Bunsen burner. The search for the truth was about to start.

The First Test: Dissolving in Water
The way a substance dissolves in water offers the first major clue.

A clear difference emerged right away! Two of the samples seemed to dissolve into a clear solution, but one turned the water cloudy and settled at the bottom. That’s right—flour. The main component of flour, starch, doesn’t “dissolve” cleanly in water like sugar or salt (it actually swells by absorbing water). With this key finding, the identity of one suspect was all but confirmed!

The Second Test: The Burn to Learn
Next, the students tried “combustion”—literally putting the suspects on trial by fire.

This test provided a definitive contrast! One sample charred black, while the other remained completely white and refused to burn. (Note: salt sometimes makes a “crackling” sound when heated due to trace moisture.)

This difference reveals a fundamental distinction in matter. The ones that charred black were sugar and flour. These are organic compounds, meaning their structure is built on a carbon backbone. When they burn (oxidize), that carbon backbone is left behind as black “charcoal.” On the other hand, the white powder that refused to burn was salt (sodium chloride). Salt is an inorganic compound that contains no carbon. Its inability to burn is a key signature of inorganic matter.

With “didn’t dissolve” (flour) and “didn’t burn” (salt) identified, the remaining suspect that “dissolved and burned” must be sugar!

Case closed… or is it? Other groups were conducting even more thorough “side investigations.”

Conductivity Test

This experiment is electrifying! The students inserted electrodes into the dissolved liquids. Sugar water does not conduct electricity because sugar dissolves as intact “molecules.” However, when they tested salt water… the current flowed! This is because salt (sodium chloride) is an electrolyte; when dissolved, it breaks apart into charged particles (ions)—sodium ions and chloride ions. Even though they look like the same clear liquid, this test exposed a profound difference in their internal makeup.

Back to Powder (Evaporation)

If it dissolved in water, let’s see if we can get it back out! This test involved heating the liquids on an evaporating dish to boil away the water.

The result was crystal clear. From the salt water, the original white salt crystals reappeared. Meanwhile, when the sugar water was heated, the sugar began to change due to the heat (caramelization) and eventually charred black, just like in the burning test. Again, this highlights the crucial difference between organic and inorganic substances.

Litmus Paper Analysis

This group decided to check the acidity/alkalinity using litmus paper. Since the suspects were salt, sugar, and flour, all of them would have been neutral, so there wouldn’t have been a big change. However, what if baking soda (weakly alkaline) or citric acid (acidic) had been among the “suspects”? This litmus paper would have been the key piece of evidence! The ability to adjust the difficulty like this is part of what makes experiments fun.

The Summary of Findings and the Thrill of Science
All investigations (experiments) concluded, and the results were compiled.

“Does it dissolve in water?” “Does it burn?” “Does it conduct electricity?” “What happens when it evaporates?” Based on their own plans, the students logically determined the identities of the white powders—which looked indistinguishable to the naked eye—by testing their various “properties.” For instance: “A didn’t burn and conducted electricity, so it’s salt.” “B didn’t dissolve in water and charred, so it’s flour.” “C dissolved in water and charred, so it’s sugar.”

This is the excitement of science. It’s not just about memorizing facts; it’s about using knowledge to pose a question, test a hypothesis, and derive the truth. We barely finished clean-up before the 50-minute class was over, but we took care of the rest!

Your own kitchen is full of “science seeds” waiting to be discovered. Why not play the role of a science detective and take a fresh look at the world around you?

Inquiries and Requests
Let’s make the wonders and excitement of science more accessible! We’ve gathered easy-to-understand tips and fun science experiments you can do at home. Feel free to search around!

The content of our science blog has been turned into a book. Find out more here.

Learn more about the administrator, Ken Kuwako, here.

For various requests (writing, lectures, experiment classes, TV supervision, appearances, etc.), click here. * Updates are posted on X!

We post experiment videos on the Kuwako Science Channel!

３月のイチオシ実験！

• 押し花を作ろう！：梅や桜の花の押し花を作ってみましょう。特別なケースに入れると、長く保存できて、しおりにもなります。

テレビ番組・科学監修等のお知らせ

• 「月曜から夜更かし」（日本テレビ）にて科学監修・出演しました。
• 2月27日放送予定「チコちゃんに叱られる」（NHK）の科学監修しました。

書籍のお知らせ

• 1/27 『見えない力と遊ぼう！電気・磁石・熱の実験』（工学社）を執筆しました。
• サクセス15 ２月号にて「浸透圧」に関する科学記事を執筆しました。
• 『大人のための高校物理復習帳』（講談社）…一般向けに日常の物理について公式を元に紐解きました。特設サイトでは実験を多数紹介しています。※増刷がかかり６刷となりました（2026/02/01）
• 『きめる!共通テスト 物理基礎 改訂版』（学研）…　高校物理の参考書です。イラストを多くしてイメージが持てるように描きました。授業についていけない、物理が苦手、そんな生徒におすすめです。特設サイトはこちら。

講師・ショー・その他お知らせ

• 3/20（金）　日本理科教育学会オンライン全国大会2026「慣性の法則の概念形成を目指した探究的な学びの実践」について発表します。B会場 第３セッション： 学習指導・教材（中学校）③　11:20-12:20
• 7/18（土）　教員向け実験講習会「ナリカカサイエンスアカデミー」の講師をします。お会いしましょう。
• 10/10（土）　秘密兵器「帯電ガン」が炸裂！ビリビリ！ドキドキ！静電気サイエンスショー＠千葉市科学フェスタ（午後予定）
• 各種SNS　X(Twitter)／instagram／Facebook／BlueSky／Threads

Explore

• 楽しい実験…お子さんと一緒に夢中になれるイチオシの科学実験を多数紹介しています。また、高校物理の理解を深めるための動画教材も用意しました。
• 理科の教材… 理科教師をバックアップ！授業の質を高め、準備を効率化するための選りすぐりの教材を紹介しています。
• Youtube…科学実験等の動画を配信しています。
• 科学ラジオ …科学トピックをほぼ毎日配信中！AI技術を駆使して作成した「耳で楽しむ科学」をお届けします。
• 講演 …全国各地で実験講習会・サイエンスショー等を行っています。
• About …「科学のネタ帳」のコンセプトや、運営者である桑子研のプロフィール・想いをまとめています。
• お問い合わせ …実験教室のご依頼、執筆・講演の相談、科学監修等はこちらのフォームからお寄せください。