What Happens When Copper and Zinc Meet Hydrochloric Acid? A “Personality Test” of Metals You Should Know Before Battery Experiments
I’m Ken Kuwako, your science trainer. Every day is an experiment!
In 9th-grade science, there is a particular unit where many students struggle, yet simultaneously find themselves captivated. That unit is “How Batteries Work.” We use smartphones and remote controls every day without a second thought. We know they run on batteries, but if someone asked, “Exactly how is that electricity created?”, surprisingly few people could give an immediate answer.
Today, I want to talk about a “little trick”—a preliminary experiment—that I always perform to help students dive deeper into the world of batteries. Instead of jumping straight into building a battery, taking a small step back is actually the fastest way to cultivate scientific thinking.
Don’t Connect Them Yet! Start with a “Solo” Conversation
Textbooks often jump straight into the procedure: take two different metals (like zinc and copper), connect them with a wire, and dunk them into hydrochloric acid. But wait just a moment!
If you show students the finished product right away, they tend to settle for a simple observation: “Oh, bubbles come out when you put them in acid.” To prevent this, I always make sure to do a preliminary test: “What happens if we put each metal into the acid one by one, all by themselves?”
Our three contenders are: a zinc plate, a copper plate, and a carbon rod.
Getting to Know Each Metal’s “Personality”
When you place these materials into hydrochloric acid individually, their unique “personalities” (differences in ionization tendency) become crystal clear. Take a look at this video:
The Zinc Plate: The moment it hits the acid, it starts fizzing vigorously. These bubbles are proof that the zinc is dissolving and generating hydrogen gas. Students usually react with a lively “Whoa, it’s actually melting!”
The Copper Plate: You drop it in and… silence. At first glance, nothing seems to be happening. No bubbles. However, when you take it out, there’s a surprising change. The dullness is gone, and the copper is now shiny and bright! This shows that the acid merely cleaned the oxidation (dirt) off the surface, but the copper itself did not dissolve.
The Carbon Rod: Finally, the carbon rod. You put it in, and… absolutely no reaction.
Etching these “solo reactions” into their minds serves as vital foreshadowing for the excitement to come.
Planting the Seeds of “Why?”
By doing this preliminary experiment, a giant question mark appears in the students’ minds the moment we finally connect the zinc and copper plates to form a battery.
“Wait a second! There weren’t any bubbles on the copper plate before… but now that they’re connected, the copper is fizzing!?”
This sense of wonder is the driving force that pushes students to understand the movement of electrons and the true nature of electric current. A phenomenon that couldn’t happen alone suddenly occurs through a connection. That is the true “magic” of a battery.
Why Include the “Carbon Rod” at All?
By the way, why do we include a non-metal like a carbon rod in our experiment?
The reason becomes clear if I show them a “disassembled manganese battery” beforehand. That black rod in the center of a standard household battery? That’s the carbon rod.
“Let’s try an experiment using the same materials found inside a real battery.”
With just that one sentence, the reaction happening in a beaker in the science lab suddenly links to the gadgets they use every day. It’s the moment the world of the textbook connects to the real world.
Sometimes, the long way around is the shortest path. By taking the time to “converse” with each individual material before building the battery, we can significantly deepen a child’s scientific curiosity.
Inquiries and Requests
Bringing the wonder and fun of science closer to you! I share easy-to-follow tips and fun experiments you can try at home. Feel free to explore more:
My “Science Notebook” series is now a book! Details here
Learn more about Ken Kuwako here
For work requests (writing, lectures, workshops, TV supervision, etc.), click here – Follow me on X (formerly Twitter) for the latest updates!
Watch experiment videos on the Science Material Channel!
